Legend, Lore, and My Four Thieves Vinegar Recipe

This recipe comes with a dose of intriguing folklore. While the plague-era tale is likely embellished, after using my Four Thieves Vinegar recipe for years I can say there is truth to the magic of this herbal blend.

History and Lore of Four Thieves Vinegar

In 1346, a plague spread through Europe. Telltale signs of the disease were fever and swollen skin sores that made the skin look black. Caused by an outbreak of Yersinia pestis, a bacteria spread by fleas, the Black Death is believed to have killed millions of Europeans in the span of a few years —a third of the continent’s population at the time.

It’s said that people used aromatic herbs to protect themselves from catching the disease. This specific legend tells of a team of grave robbers who avoided the plague with homemade preparations that included the herbs in this recipe.

As folklore is wont to do, details shift from one telling to the next. I personally heard this tale from many of my early herb teachers that I studied with in the 1980’s. Some say the four thieves wore masks soaked in vinegar, herbs, and spices. Or did they sip the aromatic vinegar? Was it used in the 1300s or during the Great Plague of Marseille in 1720?

One researcher suggests that the tale of this aromatic vinegar took shape in the 19th century, drawing on plague lore from over the centuries, with little evidence of the four thieves or their recipe.

Even so, after using and sharing my Four Thieves Vinegar recipe for years, the stories I’ve heard of ailments averted by using this vinegar could fill a book.

Herbs’ Innate Defenses

We know that aromatic herbs can defend against pathogens. The volatile oils that give these herbs their distinctive scents also have antimicrobial actions. These are plants’ innate defense against environmental stressors, including pathogens.

My Four Thieves Vinegar recipe calls upon the defenses of seven common household herbs: lavender, rosemary, sage, thyme, peppermint, and garlic, plus a little black pepper.

Lavender

The aromatic oils in lavender have been shown to have antibacterial activity against clinical strains of bacteria, and may also help stimulate the immune system.

Rosemary

According to a study comparing aromatic herbs, rosemary is one of the best broad-spectrum antibacterial agents, possibly the strongest on this list. It also has antifungal properties.

Sage

Common sage has antiviral and antibacterial activity attributed in part to the fragrant compounds camphor and thujone.

Thyme

Thyme has been found to have moderately broad antimicrobial activity and is used for situations specific to the sinus and lungs.

Peppermint

Peppermint has notable antimicrobial activity, though not as broad as rosemary or thyme.

Garlic

Fresh garlic offers potent protection against bacteria, fungi, and viruses. This is one herbal medicine that still holds its lore in modern culture. Even if someone is not interested in herbal knowledge, they have it in their mind that garlic fights off colds. You can find out more about how I like to use garlic, here: Most Used Herbal Medicine: Garlic for Colds and Flu Prevention

Black Pepper

Black pepper has excellent antimicrobial activity, thanks to piperine, terpenes, and flavones. It also acts as a “driver” in the formula, stimulating circulation to help get the compounds where they need to go.

Apple Cider Vinegar

As a fermented food, apple cider vinegar has been shown to have antimicrobial properties even before it is infused with aromatic herbs.

A true folk remedy, the specifics of the original recipe are unknown. Many herbalists have perfected their own version of Four Thieves Vinegar. Here’s mine.

Print Recipe

Four Thieves Vinegar Recipe

From my book, The Herbal Kitchen

Author: Kami McBride

Ingredients

• 1/2 cup finely chopped fresh lavender
• 1/2 cup finely chopped fresh rosemary
• 1/4 cup finely chopped fresh sage
• 1/4 cup finely chopped fresh thyme
• 2 tbsp finely chopped fresh peppermint
• 3 garlic cloves, finely chopped
• 1 tbsp powdered black pepper
• 3 cups apple cider vinegar

Instructions

• Fill a quart-size glass jar with the herbs and spices.
• Pour vinegar over the ingredients, filling the jar to the top with vinegar. The vinegar should cover the ingredients by at least a couple of inches.
• Close the lid. If you’re using a metal lid, cover the opening of the jar with two sheets of wax paper before putting the lid on. Plastic lids work well for this recipe.
• Store vinegar in a cool dark place for one month. Shake it once in a while and occasionally check to see if you need to add more vinegar, as some might get soaked up by the plant material. If the herbs are sticking out above the vinegar, add more vinegar.

Decant

• After one month, strain the herbs from the vinegar.
• Place a funnel into the opening of a clean, sterilized jar. Lay muslin over the top of the funnel. 
• Pour your infused vinegar through the muslin.
• Let the vinegar strain through the cloth and funnel into the clean jar.
• Don’t squeeze the muslin, as that will squeeze water from the plant material, shortening the shelf life of your vinegar and making it cloudy.
• Discard the strained ingredients into the compost. The liquid left behind is your herbal vinegar.

Notes

To use: Take a tablespoon each morning to help support your immunity. If you have a sensitive stomach, then dilute in water. This zesty flavor also works well added to salad dressings, marinades, and bloody Mary's as a delicious way to bring kitchen magic into your home.

Storage: Store your herbal vinegar in a container with a plastic or cork lid, as the vinegar will corrode metal. Place the container in a cabinet away from heat and light, and in a place with consistent temperatures. Your vinegar should last for about one year. If it turns black, has floating chunks, mold, or a funny smell, throw it away.

Ready to seriously herbify your kitchen pantry? Check out My Herbal Kitchen

I would love to hear from you! Have you used this Four Thieves Vinegar recipe? Share your story in the comments below.